← Google Interview Insights

Google·Software Engineer·Onsite - Coding / Algorithms·Intermediate

IntermediatePrefer not to say
Jul 2026

Summary

Google SWE coding round with a bin-packing style problem involving two resource dimensions. Not the hardest problem on paper but the two-constraint angle made greedy approaches fall apart pretty fast.

Questions Asked (1)

Q1

Given N machines each consuming two types of resources, and racks with fixed capacity limits on both resource types, find the minimum number of racks needed to fit all machines. Return -1 if any machine exceeds either capacity limit.

Algorithms & Data StructuresTechnical Trade-offs
Author's notes

My first instinct was a greedy sort on one dimension and I ran with it way too long before realizing it breaks on the second constraint.

Create a free account to read the full note

AI HintsAI Generated

Suggested Approach

First, validate that no machine exceeds the rack capacity limits; if any does, return -1. Then, model the problem as a 2D bin packing problem and propose a greedy heuristic (e.g., sort machines by one resource and use a best-fit strategy) to minimize the number of racks. Discuss the NP-hardness and potential exact solutions for small N, but focus on practical heuristics for large N.

Pro tip: Acknowledge the NP-hard nature of 2D bin packing and emphasize that while exact solutions are impractical for large N, well-designed heuristics can achieve near-optimal results; this shows you understand real-world trade-offs.

1. Input Validation

Check if any machine's resource consumption exceeds the rack's capacity in either dimension. If so, return -1 immediately.

2. Problem Modeling

Recognize this as a 2D bin packing problem where machines are items and racks are bins with two capacity constraints. Note that it is NP-hard.

3. Algorithm Selection

Choose an appropriate approach based on N: for small N, consider exact methods like branch-and-bound; for large N, use heuristics like First-Fit Decreasing or Best-Fit with sorting.

4. Heuristic Design

Design a greedy heuristic: sort machines by one resource (e.g., CPU) descending, then place each machine into the first rack that can accommodate both resources, possibly using a best-fit strategy to minimize waste.

5. Complexity and Trade-offs

Analyze time and space complexity of the chosen approach, and discuss trade-offs between optimality and efficiency, mentioning that heuristics may not always yield the minimum but are practical.

Key Points to Mention

  • NP-hardness of 2D bin packing and implications for exact solutions
  • Greedy heuristics like First-Fit Decreasing and Best-Fit
  • Sorting machines by resource consumption to improve packing efficiency
  • Handling the -1 case for machines exceeding capacity
  • Time and space complexity analysis of the proposed algorithm
  • Potential use of approximation algorithms or integer programming for small N

AI-generated suggestions, not part of the candidate's original notes. May be inaccurate — verify before relying on them.