← Openai Interview Insights

Openai·Software Engineer·Technical Phone Screen·Senior

SeniorPrefer not to say
May 2026Remote

Summary

Got a NumPy implementation question at OpenAI for a SWE role, the kind of thing that looks clean on paper but has enough gotchas to trip you up if you haven't thought carefully about numerical stability before.

Questions Asked (1)

Q1

Implement numerically stable softmax cross-entropy loss and its gradient with respect to the input logits from scratch in NumPy, no autograd allowed.

Algorithms & Data StructuresTechnical Trade-offs
Author's notes

The numerically stable part is where people slip up.

Create a free account to read the full note

AI HintsAI Generated

Suggested Approach

Start by explaining the numerical instability of naive softmax and the standard log-sum-exp trick. Then derive the gradient of the loss with respect to logits, showing that it simplifies to (softmax - one_hot) / N. Finally, implement both forward and backward passes in NumPy, ensuring stability by subtracting the max logit before exponentiation.

Pro tip: Emphasize that the gradient simplifies to (softmax - one_hot) / N, which is both elegant and efficient. Also, mention that you can reuse the softmax probabilities from the forward pass in the backward pass to save computation.

1. Explain numerical instability and the log-sum-exp trick

Describe why computing exp(logits) directly can overflow, and how subtracting the maximum logit before exponentiation stabilizes the computation without changing the result.

2. Derive the forward pass for softmax cross-entropy loss

Show that the loss for a single example is -log(softmax(logits)[true_class]), and using the log-sum-exp trick, it becomes -logits[true_class] + max_logit + log(sum(exp(logits - max_logit))).

3. Derive the gradient of the loss with respect to logits

Compute the gradient by differentiating the loss, yielding (softmax(logits) - one_hot(true_class)) / N for a batch of N examples.

4. Implement the forward and backward passes in NumPy

Write vectorized code for a batch: compute max_logits, shifted_logits, exp_shifted, sum_exp, log_probs, and loss; then compute softmax probabilities and the gradient using the simplified formula.

5. Test and validate the implementation

Verify correctness by comparing with a naive implementation on small inputs, and check numerical stability with large logits. Optionally, use finite differences to validate the gradient.

Key Points to Mention

  • Log-sum-exp trick for numerical stability
  • Derivation of the gradient: softmax - one_hot
  • Vectorized implementation for efficiency
  • Avoiding overflow/underflow by subtracting max logit
  • Reusing softmax probabilities from forward pass in backward pass
  • Handling batches by averaging the loss and gradient

AI-generated suggestions, not part of the candidate's original notes. May be inaccurate — verify before relying on them.